Everything We Know So Far About With a Vengeance by Riley Sager
- Casey
- Apr 15
- 3 min read
Fellow Riley Sager fans, mark your calendars—because 2025 is shaping up to be another thrilling year. With the announcement of his upcoming novel With a Vengeance, anticipation is already building, and the mystery community is buzzing with speculation. Known for twisting psychological thrillers like Final Girls, Home Before Dark, and The House Across the Lake, Sager’s latest promises a return to high-stakes suspense—with, as the title suggests, a powerful dose of vengeance.
So, what exactly do we know so far? Let’s break it down.
🔥 The Title - With a Vengeance: What’s in a Name?
The title With a Vengeance is bold, ominous, and unmistakably Sager. While his previous titles often carry a tone of mystery or foreboding (Lock Every Door, Survive the Night), this one hits harder—it implies that this story may center around revenge, justice, or retribution. The use of "vengeance" suggests personal stakes and a protagonist who may not be as passive or reactive as we've seen in some of his past novels.
Could this be Sager’s grittiest book yet? Quite possibly.
📚 Plot Teasers and Publisher Hints
While the full synopsis hasn’t been released at the time of writing, publisher blurbs and early marketing drops suggest that With a Vengeance will feature:
A female lead haunted by a traumatic past
A cold case that’s suddenly thrust back into the spotlight
A remote, isolated setting (classic Sager)
And yes—an undercurrent of revenge that may blur the line between hero and villain
Riley Sager is no stranger to morally complex protagonists, and if early clues are correct, With a Vengeance may take this to the next level.
🕵️♀️ Themes to Expect
Based on his literary track record and the direction this title suggests, readers can expect With a Vengeance to explore:
Revenge vs. Justice: How far is too far when righting a wrong?
Memory and Trauma: A familiar Sager motif—what happens when the past refuses to stay buried?
Isolation and Paranoia: Whether it’s a remote house, a dark forest, or a deserted college campus, Sager excels at placing characters in environments where tension thrives.
The Unreliable Narrator: Will we be able to trust our protagonist this time? Probably not—and that’s half the fun.
Grab a magnetic bookmark in our shop!
📅 Release Date and Preorders
According to early reports from Sager’s publisher (Dutton Books), With a Vengeance is slated for release in [insert confirmed date here once available—likely Summer 2025]. Preorders aren’t open yet, but given Sager’s loyal fan base, expect signed editions, exclusive covers, and maybe even a special book tour.
Be sure to follow his official channels or sign up for his newsletter for updates—and keep an eye on indie bookstores for preorder perks.
🔮 Fan Theories and Speculation
Riley Sager fans are already spinning theories based on tiny breadcrumbs. Some believe the book may connect subtly to The Last Time I Lied or even feature a returning character under a new name. Others speculate the setting may involve a former psychiatric facility or a remote island—a classic setting for revenge stories where justice gets… personal.
Until more details are revealed, the possibilities are endless.
Final Thoughts
With a Vengeance has all the makings of a Riley Sager hit: gripping suspense, murky motives, and a central mystery that will keep readers flipping pages late into the night. While the full story remains under wraps, one thing is clear—Sager knows exactly how to keep us hooked, and this next book might just be his most intense ride yet.
Stay tuned to this blog—we’ll be updating as soon as new information drops, and you can bet we’ll have a spoiler-free review ready the day it hits shelves.
Are you excited for With a Vengeance? What do you hope to see in Sager’s next thriller? Drop your predictions in the comments below!
Comments